Indiana Hoosiers Basketball: IU Was Never What the Hype Portrayed

Use your ← → (arrows) to browse

College basketball is suffering from “dominant team deficiency” disorder.

So desperate is the sport for a prohibitive favorite like last year’s Kentucky that it has mythologized one team to fill the void, worthiness be damned. The thinking: if there isn’t a truly deserving No. 1 team, make one up and sell it well.

Feb 07, 2013; Champaign, IL, USA; Indiana Hoosiers head coach Tom Crean talks to forward Will Sheehey (0) during the second half against the Illinois Fighting Illini at Assembly Hall. Illinois defeated Indiana 74-72. Mandatory Credit: Bradley Leeb-USA TODAY Sports

And so a spurious “team to beat” was born.

The college hoops community has done everything it can to exalt Indiana as the nation’s golden standard. AP voters have tried to convince the masses Tom Crean’s assembly is a cut above the rest. The writers gave preferential treatment to Indiana earlier this month, allowing the Hoosiers to retain their No. 1 ranking even after squandering a late double-digit lead to Illinois in the preceding week. No other top-ranked team this season has held onto the coveted spot after losing the week before.

Say it enough and eventually it will become true –that’s been the media’s rationale in fabricating a dominant team. Too bad the self-fulfilling prophecy hasn’t materialized. Overlook the sugarcoated perception and you’ll find the Bloomington beast has been no more beastly than any other outfit ranked in the Top 10.

Indiana is no closer to staking a fair claim as the nation’s best team than Gonzaga, Duke, Miami, Michigan, New Mexico or Georgetown. The Hoosiers are one of at least a dozen bona fide Final Four contenders differentiated only under the guise of a lofty preseason billing. Just don’t make the mistake, as many have, of confusing past projection with present performance.

Judging by overall body of work, there’s certainly nothing exemplary about what the troopers from Assembly Hall have accomplished. IU’s résumé is indistinguishable from –perhaps even inferior to — the portfolio assembled by New Mexico. Seriously, see for yourself. Where are the cries for the Lobos to pin down the No. 1 overall seed in March? Heck, where’s the movement to get Steve Alford’s team one-line consideration of any kind?

Use your ← → (arrows) to browse
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: Basketball Indiana Hoosiers

  • Daren Collentine

    All four of their losses are to tournament teams. Name one other school that can say that? 7 top 25 wins, 4 top ten wins, 2 top 5 wins. 2 top 10 road wins and one top5 road win…….. can anyone else say that? No loss was more than 5 points also (two were game winners)

    • evanwilliamsbustingbrackets

      You’re arbitrarily changing between criteria here. Some of your resume bullets are based upon rankings at the time the games were played. Others use current rankings.

      Indiana lost to Butler, Wisconsin and Illinois all when those teams were unranked, so Indiana has lost to unranked teams in 75% of its losses. Gonzaga hasn’t lost to a ranked team judging by the current rankings either.

      Duke has three wins over Top 5 teams (Kentucky, Louisville, Ohio State) as opposed to Indiana’s two, and neither set of Top 5 wins is nearly as impressive now as it was when they were recorded Wisconsin has a comparable collection of quality wins, including one at Indiana. Wisconsin is the only team in the land with with wins over a pair of teams currently ranked in the Top 5.

      And as outlined in the article, New Mexico has a slightly more complete resume than Indiana’s (the two are neck-and-neck).

      The Hoosiers are really good. Legitimate Final Four threat still. But they were never the dominant team so many folks were hoping they’d become. At least not yet.

      • Daren Collentine

        If you use current rankings or RPI then their resume is even better. They beat Georgetown when they weren’t ranked and look at them.

  • John Goulet

    IU has played all of 10 minutes in “above questioned zone” defense. That’s probably how much you have seen of the Hoosiers!
    Although you talk a good game your Indiana hating is off the charts!

    Still stinging from that 87′ National Championship LOSS, huh Evan!

  • Eric Lewis

    Ridiculous. IU has lost four games by a total 14 points. What was that Duke Miami score again?